Disclosure: We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. How we make money.
Short answer: if you’re grading a card you may sell, start with PSA. Its slabs have the biggest resale market, and in an October 2026 study of eBay sales, other graders’ standard 10s mostly sold for less than a PSA 10 of the same card. CGC is the low-cost option, and its Pristine 10 label resells close to PSA. TAG stands out for detailed digital reports, and its 10s sold level with PSA in that study. Beckett is for people who want subgrades or are chasing a Black Label.
If you’re grading cards just to keep, choose whichever open tier is cheapest and turns around fastest. Here’s how they compare.
The four graders in one table
| PSA | CGC | Beckett (BGS) | TAG | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Top label | Gem Mint 10 | Pristine 10 (above Gem Mint 10) | Black Label Pristine 10 | Pristine 10 (score 990–1000) |
| Subgrades | No | Not on the standard label | Yes: centering, corners, edges, surface | 1,000-point score plus digital report |
| Cheapest published card tier (2026) | Value, $39.99 | Bulk, $17 (Mar 2026 announcement) | Base tiers from $14.95 listed, but not open on Nov 9, 2026 (third-party reading) | Value/Base listed; Standard $59.95 |
| Resale of a 10 vs PSA 10 (Pokémon, Jul–Oct 2026) | 100% (benchmark) | Gem Mint 10: 38%; Pristine 10: 96% | BGS 9.5: 51% (10s not broken out) | TAG 10: 100% |
| eBay Authenticity Guarantee grader | Yes | Yes | Yes | Not listed |
Fee sources and caveats are in our when to grade a Pokémon card guide, which has the full 2026 fee table. Resale percentages are from UltraBall’s October 2026 study of verified eBay US sales of English Pokémon cards.
How each grader’s scale works
All four use a 1-to-10 scale, but the top of the scale differs, and that matters for resale.
PSA
PSA’s top grade is Gem Mint 10, described as “a virtually perfect card” with sharp corners, full original gloss and centering within about 55/45 on the front and 75/25 on the back. There are no subgrades on the label. Simple labels, the biggest population of graded cards, and broad buyer recognition are PSA’s main strengths.
CGC
CGC splits the top of its scale in two:
- Pristine 10: “a virtually flawless card to the naked eye,” with 50/50 centering and flawless color and registration. It gets a special Pristine label.
- Gem Mint 10: a 10 overall where one criterion falls short of Pristine; centering not to exceed about 55/45 front and 75/25 back.
That split is why resale numbers for CGC need care. In UltraBall’s data, a CGC Gem Mint 10 sold for 38% of the same card’s PSA 10, closer to a PSA 9 (22%) than a PSA 10, while a CGC Pristine 10 sold for 96%.
Beckett (BGS)
Beckett grades in half-point steps and reports four subgrades: centering, corners, edges and surface. A Black Label Pristine 10 requires a 10 in all four subgrades. Third-party guides describe a Gold Label for other Pristine 10s and Gem Mint 9.5s. Subgrades help a buyer see why a card got its grade, which some collectors value.
In UltraBall’s data, a BGS 9.5 sold for 51% of a PSA 10. The study didn’t report a figure for BGS 10s.
TAG
TAG gives each card a score from 100 to 1000 along with the familiar 1-10 grade. Its scale page says 950–989 is Gem Mint 10 and 990–1000 is Pristine. TAG’s help center says every tier includes imaging and a digital grading report. In UltraBall’s data, a TAG 10 sold for 100% of a PSA 10.
One practical drawback: eBay’s Authenticity Guarantee page for trading cards lists PSA, SGC, CGC Trading Cards, CSG and Beckett as accepted graders for graded cards, and TAG isn’t on that list as of November 2026.
What it costs (and why it keeps changing)
Grading fees moved a lot in 2026. As of November 21, 2026:
- PSA reopened its Value tier on October 29, 2026 at $39.99 per card (up to $500 insured value). Standard is $59.99 and Priority $79.99. PSA’s Collectors Club-only Value Bulk service was still paused.
- CGC announced Bulk at $17 and Economy at $20 effective March 24, 2026. We couldn’t load a newer CGC fee table.
- TAG lists Standard at $59.95 and Priority at $79.95; Value and Base tiers are listed without prices on the page we read.
- Beckett lists Base tiers from $14.95, but a dated third-party reading on November 9, 2026 found only Express ($79.95) open to order.
Shipping both ways and any upcharges come on top. Always check the live price page the day you submit.
A worked example (hypothetical card)
Suppose a card’s PSA 10 sells for $200. Using UltraBall’s October 2026 median ratios, the same card in other holders might be expected to sell for roughly:
| Grade | Median share of PSA 10 | Hypothetical sale |
|---|---|---|
| PSA 10 | 100% | $200 |
| TAG 10 | 100% | $200 |
| CGC Pristine 10 | 96% | $192 |
| BGS 9.5 | 51% | $102 |
| CGC Gem Mint 10 | 38% | $76 |
| PSA 9 | 22% | $44 |
The $200 figure is made up to show the method. Real cards vary a lot around these medians, so always check sold prices for your specific card. The example shows why the label matters more than the number: a “10” from one company can sell for less than half of a “10” from another.
Verify the slab when you buy graded
Fake slabs exist. Every major grader lets you look up a certification number on its website. Before buying a graded card, check that the cert number exists, that the card, grade and label match the listing photos, and that the holder shows no signs of tampering. eBay’s Authenticity Guarantee also checks eligible graded cards listed or sold for $200 or more, for the graders on its list.
How to choose: a simple decision path
- Will you sell the card? If yes, PSA is the default. Check recent sold prices for your exact card in PSA, CGC Pristine, TAG and BGS slabs; if a cheaper grader’s slabs sell nearly as well for that card, the savings may win.
- Is it for your own collection? Pick the cheapest open tier that fits the card’s value. CGC’s published bulk price was the lowest of the four.
- Do you want to know exactly why it got its grade? Beckett’s subgrades or TAG’s report give the most detail.
- Is it a near-perfect card? The “Pristine” labels (CGC Pristine 10, TAG Pristine, BGS Black Label) are where the extra value lives, but they’re hard to get. Be realistic.
- Is the card worth less than the fee? Don’t grade it. A sleeve and toploader protect it for pennies.
Before you submit anywhere
- Pre-screen the card. Check centering, corners, edges and surface under bright light. Most pack-fresh cards aren’t 10s.
- Pack it correctly. PSA asks for a penny sleeve inside a 3 5/16” x 4 7/8” semi-rigid holder and no toploaders. Our holders guide explains the difference.
- Make sure it’s real. Graders return counterfeits ungraded, and you still pay. See how to spot fake Pokémon cards.
- Run the break-even math from our grading guide: expected graded value minus all costs has to beat the raw value.
Example supplies: Card Saver I semi-rigid holders (store link coming soon) · PSA-graded Pokémon cards on eBay (store link coming soon)
Whichever grader you choose, prep matters. Our grading prep guide covers centering checks, safe dust removal and the alterations that can get a card rejected.
Bottom line
For beginners who might sell, PSA is the safest first choice. CGC is the budget option, but know that a regular CGC Gem Mint 10 has resold for far less than a PSA 10, while a Pristine 10 resells close to it. TAG’s 10s have held up well against PSA and come with detailed reports, though TAG isn’t on eBay’s Authenticity Guarantee list. Beckett is the specialist’s choice for subgrades. Whatever you pick, check the open tiers and live prices on submission day.
Sources
- PSA, Grading Standards (Gem Mint 10 definition and centering): https://www.psacard.com/gradingstandards
- PSA, “Pricing and Estimated Turnaround Time Updates,” read November 21, 2026: https://www.psacard.com/info/submission-updates
- CGC, Grading Scales (Pristine 10 and Gem Mint 10 definitions), read November 21, 2026: https://www.cgcgrading.com/grading-scales/
- CGC, “CGC Updates Bulk and Economy Tiers for Card Submissions,” March 10, 2026: https://www.cgcgrading.com/news/articles/cgc-updates-bulk-economy-tiers-39EPnFbgfEFcl9dg16hFnr/
- TAG, Grading Scale (100–1000 score; 950–989 Gem Mint 10; 990–1000 Pristine), read November 21, 2026: https://taggrading.com/pages/scale
- TAG Help Center, “What are TAG’s Available Grading Services?”, October 21, 2026: https://help.taggrading.com/en/articles/10692075-what-are-tag-s-available-grading-services
- Beckett, grading services page (subgrades and labels): https://beckett.com/grading
- BinderMint, “How much does Beckett grading cost?”, updated November 10, 2026: https://bindermint.com/guides/beckett-grading-cost
- UltraBall Research, “What a PSA 10 is worth” (October 2026 edition; eBay US sales July 15 to October 12, 2026): https://ultraball.com/news/data/psa-10-premium-october-2026
- eBay, Authenticity Guarantee for Trading Cards (accepted graders, $200 threshold), read November 21, 2026: https://www.ebay.com/authenticity-guarantee/tradingcards
Couldn't verify: CGC's current fee table after March 2026; TAG's Value and Base prices on TAG's own site; Beckett's live tier availability and its label rules on Beckett's own page (the Gold Label description comes from third-party guides); resale figures for BGS 10s. The resale percentages are medians for English Pokémon cards only and may differ for other games.
Frequently asked questions
- Which grading company is best for beginners?
- For a card you might sell, PSA is the safest default because its graded cards have the deepest resale market. CGC and TAG can make sense for lower cost or detailed reports, and Beckett mainly appeals for subgrades and its Black Label. Compare the tiers that are open the day you submit.
- Is a CGC 10 worth as much as a PSA 10?
- Usually not. An October 2026 study of eBay sales found a CGC Gem Mint 10 Pokémon card sold for a median 38% of the same card's PSA 10, while CGC's stricter Pristine 10 sold for 96%.
- What is a Beckett Black Label?
- Beckett gives subgrades for centering, corners, edges and surface. A Black Label Pristine 10 means all four subgrades are 10, which is rare and usually sells at a premium.
- What's the cheapest way to get a Pokémon card graded in 2026?
- On published prices, CGC's bulk tier was the lowest at $17 per card as of its March 2026 announcement, against $39.99 for PSA's Value tier after its October 29, 2026 update. Minimums, shipping and open tiers change, so check each grader's page before submitting.
- Does TAG grading count for eBay's Authenticity Guarantee?
- As of November 2026, eBay's Authenticity Guarantee page for trading cards lists PSA, SGC, CGC Trading Cards, CSG and Beckett as the accepted graders for graded cards. TAG wasn't on that list.