Disclosure: We may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page, at no extra cost to you. How we make money.
Short answer: good grading prep removes preventable problems without changing the card. Inspect under angled light, check centering against PSA’s published Gem Mint standard (about 55/45 front, 75/25 back), wipe away only loose dust with a clean soft microfiber cloth, put the card in a fresh penny sleeve and a semi-rigid holder, and pack it so nothing moves. Never use liquids, erasers, pressing or trimming: PSA lists cleaning solutions, pressing and other alterations as reasons a card can come back without a numeric grade.
If you’re still deciding whether a card is worth grading at all, start with when to grade a Pokémon card and our PSA vs CGC vs Beckett vs TAG comparison.
What you need
| Item | Why | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Clean, soft work mat | Keeps cards off a hard, gritty desk | A clean playmat works |
| Bright, adjustable light | Angled light reveals scratches and print lines | A prep guide recommends a daylight-temperature panel |
| Magnifier or loupe | Corners, edges and surface | Optional but helpful |
| Ruler or centering tool | Measuring borders | Millimeter scale |
| Clean microfiber cloth | Removing loose dust only | Keep it just for cards |
| Fresh penny sleeves | First layer of protection | See our penny sleeve guide |
| Semi-rigid holders | Standard for PSA submissions | Card Saver I style |
| Stiff cardboard or protectors, a sturdy box, padding | Shipping | Keep the stack from moving |
Example listing: Card Saver I semi-rigid holders (store link coming soon)
Step 1: Set up a clean workspace
GradingPrep’s guide starts here, and it’s the easiest step to skip:
- Wash and dry your hands. Skip hand lotion.
- Work on a soft, clean mat, never a bare desk.
- Handle cards by the edges.
- Lift cards; don’t slide them across any surface.
- Keep sleeves, cloths and tools separate so grit doesn’t move between them.
Step 2: Inspect before you touch anything
Look at the card front and back under angled (“raking”) light. Check four areas:
Corners
Look for whitening, softness, fraying or bends. On modern cards aiming for a 10, even small corner wear matters.
Edges
Look for chipping, whitening, rough cuts or dents. Dark borders make edge wear easy to see.
Surface
Tilt the card slowly. Look for scratches, print lines, dimples, indentations, roller marks, fingerprints, dust and stains. Foil and holo cards hide scratches until the light hits them at the right angle.
Centering
Covered in detail in the next step.
Write down what you find. GradingPrep suggests a one-line note per card (for example, “soft top-right corner, 60/40, light print line”). That note makes the decision to submit or keep raw much clearer.
Step 3: Check centering
PSA’s grading standards say a PSA Gem Mint 10 must be centered within approximately 55/45 on the front and 75/25 on the back. PSA also notes that graders may allow a small variance based on eye appeal, so measurements near the line can go either way.
How to measure
- Measure the left and right borders on the front in millimeters.
- Divide the larger border by the sum of both. That’s the bigger side’s percentage.
- Repeat for top and bottom.
- Repeat both on the back, using the back’s looser standard.
| Left border | Right border | Calculation | Centering |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2.0 mm | 2.0 mm | 2.0 / 4.0 | 50/50 |
| 2.2 mm | 1.8 mm | 2.2 / 4.0 | 55/45 (at the PSA 10 front limit) |
| 2.4 mm | 1.6 mm | 2.4 / 4.0 | 60/40 (outside PSA 10 front limit) |
| 3.0 mm | 1.0 mm | 3.0 / 4.0 | 75/25 (at the PSA 10 back limit) |
The example measurements are ours, for illustration. Use the same method on your card.
If a card’s front centering is clearly outside 55/45, a 10 from PSA is unlikely no matter how clean the rest of the card is. That’s often the deciding factor between submitting and keeping a card raw.
Step 4: Remove loose dust, and nothing else
This is where restraint matters most.
Safe: a light pass with a clean, extremely soft microfiber cloth and almost no pressure to lift loose dust, fibers or a light fingerprint on a glossy surface. If something doesn’t come off easily, stop.
Not safe: GradingPrep lists abrasive compounds, erasers, household cleaners, alcohol, whitening products, waxes and polishes as things to avoid. It also says to be especially cautious with vintage and uncoated card stock, where the safest cleaning is often none at all.
PSA’s own no-grade definitions explain why:
- N5 Altered Stock covers alterations such as paper restoration, crease or wrinkle pressing, scratch removal or enhanced gloss, and foreign substances like cleaning spray or wax on the surface.
- N7 Evidence of Cleaning covers whiteners on borders or solutions used to remove stains, and foreign substances like cleaning spray or wax.
- PSA also won’t grade cards with evidence of trimming, recoloring or restoration.
PSA says it charges the grading fee in these cases. In other words, aggressive “cleaning” can cost you a grading fee and leave you with an ungraded card.
A useful rule from GradingPrep: a scratch is not dirt, a print line is not dirt, a stain is not dirt. Grade the card with them, or keep it raw.
Step 5: Reinspect and decide
After removing dust, look again under the same light. Clean surfaces can reveal scratches and print lines that dust was hiding.
Then ask the question GradingPrep suggests: if this card comes back one grade lower than I hope, does submitting still make sense? If not, keep it raw. Grading costs money and time, and a lower grade can be worth less than you expect. Our when to grade guide covers fees and value math.
Step 6: Sleeve it once, correctly
For PSA submissions, GradingPrep describes the standard format as a penny sleeve inside a semi-rigid holder such as Card Saver I. Its other tips:
- One card per holder.
- Don’t force a card into a tight sleeve or holder.
- Don’t tape holders closed.
- Don’t add sticky notes or pull tabs unless the grader asks for them.
- Keep cards in the same order as your submission form.
Sleeve each card once, with clean hands, and then leave it alone. Repeated re-sleeving is a common cause of new corner damage. Our toploaders vs card savers guide explains the difference between holder types.
Example listing: penny sleeves for grading submissions (store link coming soon)
Step 7: Pack and ship
- Stack cards in order between stiff cardboard or purpose-made protectors, held firmly but not tight enough to bend holders.
- Use a sturdy box with padding so the stack can’t move.
- Check the cards match your submission form and include any required paperwork.
- Photograph the cards and the packed box.
- Use tracking, and insure valuable shipments. GradingPrep also recommends signature confirmation.
Always check your grading company’s current submission instructions before shipping; requirements can change.
Prepping a batch of cards
Many people submit several cards at once to share shipping costs. A few habits keep a batch organized:
- Prep one card at a time. Finish inspection, dusting and sleeving before picking up the next card.
- Number your notes to match the order on your submission form.
- Sort out the “maybes” early. Cards that fail your centering or surface checks go back into storage, not into the box.
- Take a quick photo of each card front and back before sleeving. It’s a record of condition if anything happens in transit.
- Recount before sealing the box. The card count, order and form should all match.
Prep checklist
| Check | Pass? |
|---|---|
| Hands clean, card handled by edges | |
| Corners and edges inspected under angled light | |
| Surface inspected for scratches, print lines, dents | |
| Front centering within about 55/45 (for a PSA 10 attempt) | |
| Back centering within about 75/25 | |
| Loose dust removed with dry microfiber only | |
| No liquids, erasers, pressing or trimming | |
| Fresh penny sleeve, semi-rigid holder, correct order | |
| Packed tight, photographed, tracked and insured |
Common mistakes to avoid
- Using any liquid or cleaning spray. PSA lists cleaning solutions and foreign substances as reasons for a no-grade.
- Pressing out a bend. PSA calls pressing altered stock.
- Wiping hard or in circles. Pressure can scratch foil surfaces.
- Submitting off-center cards hoping for a 10. Measure first.
- Shipping in loose toploaders or envelopes. Follow the grader’s packing rules and use a sturdy box.
Bottom line
Prep is about honesty, not improvement: inspect carefully, measure centering, remove only loose dust with a dry soft cloth, and protect the card from the moment you inspect it until it reaches the grader. Anything that changes the card, including liquids, pressing and trimming, risks a no-grade under PSA’s published standards. If the card fails your own checks, keeping it raw is a perfectly good outcome.
Sources
- PSA, Grading Standards (PSA 10 centering tolerance, ungradable cards and no-grade definitions N1 to N9), read November 21, 2026: https://www.psacard.com/gradingstandards
- GradingPrep, “How to Prep Cards for Grading: 6 Steps Before You Submit” (workspace, inspection, cleaning limits, sleeving and packing), read November 21, 2026: https://www.gradingprep.com/guides/how-to-prep-cards-for-grading
Couldn't verify: the current submission packaging requirements for CGC, Beckett and TAG (check each company's instructions); PSA's centering tolerances for grades below 10 (the grade definitions we read showed only the PSA 10 standard); whether any particular cloth or light is better than another. Grading standards and submission rules can change.
Frequently asked questions
- Should I clean a card before grading?
- Only remove loose dust or a light fingerprint with a clean, very soft microfiber cloth and almost no pressure. PSA's standards say cards with evidence of cleaning, such as whiteners or solutions used to remove stains, or foreign substances like cleaning spray or wax, can be returned without a numeric grade.
- What centering do you need for a PSA 10?
- PSA's published standard for a Gem Mint 10 allows centering of approximately 55/45 on the front and 75/25 on the back. Graders can make small allowances based on eye appeal.
- How do I measure card centering?
- Measure the border width on opposite sides, then divide the larger border by the total of both. For example, borders of 2.2 mm and 1.8 mm give 2.2 / 4.0 = 55%, or 55/45. Check left/right and top/bottom on both front and back.
- Should I send cards for grading in toploaders?
- Check your grading company's current instructions. For PSA, semi-rigid holders such as Card Saver I are the standard submission format, with the card in a penny sleeve first.
- Can pressing a card remove a bend before grading?
- Don't do it. PSA lists crease or wrinkle pressing as altered stock, which can lead to no numeric grade. Grade the card as it is or keep it raw.